Skip to main content

Can a Scarred Soul be Redeemed?

After finishing reading The Picture of Dorian Grey, something that really stood out to me was how fake Dorian's "redemption" was. At the end of the novel, we learn that Dorian is trying to "better" himself. He boasts to Lord Henry that he has become a changed man, as he "spared" Hetty from the corruptions of associating with him. The novel also deals with the theme of redemption. As Dorian comes to grapple with the fact that living life as Mr. Faust will always lead him to carry burdens that a pretty, young face won't be able to solve, he wonders if he will ever be able to reach full redemption.

However, none of his actions seem to indicate that he is truly sorry for his actions. As always, Dorian is simply fixated on outward impressions. He would like to label himself as a new man, but he is unwilling to put in the effort to become one. He still feels no regret for the death of Basil Hallward, and he still justifies it, as he believes it's Basil's fault for painting the portrait of him, not his own for making the reckless wish in the first place. He also celebrates when James Vane is found dead, as he cares more about his own safety than living up to the consequences of his Hedonistic lifestyle.

Although Dorian might have believed that his soul was irredeemable, I would beg to differ. Of course, sins such as murder and the corruption of others will always remain on his hands, it is completely possible to change and become a better person. Many people lament, "I'm not the same person I was fifteen years ago," and they very well could be correct. One's self at the present is only dependent on the actions and beliefs that he/she possesses at the current moment. Their past self is not an indication of how they are right now. Whether or not Dorian could have ever been redeemed is a subjective matter, but if he truly believed in changing himself, he definitely could have worked towards it. 

Comments

  1. I agree. But I think the fact that Dorian started off as someone so pure and innocent made him much more susceptible to the corruption and all the ideas that can only justify his situation in a wrong way as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, I also think he used the "I'm too far gone to be redeemed" line as an excuse to not put in the effort of changing his ways. He was willfully ignorant of how bad his hedonistic lifestyle was and continued being a bad person.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Talking Tamil

In class last week, we looked at two different interpretations on what it felt like to be an outsider society. We read Firoozeh Dumas's piece on what it meant to have a foreign name in America, and David Sedaris talked about how it felt to not understand French in a French class (with a scary teacher as well). I also feel that in some ways, I can relate to these two authors. I grew up speaking Tamil, just as the rest of the members of my family had done. I never went to daycare like other children did, so my only exposure to English for the first four years of my life was the television. With this in mind, you can probably tell I never really had an American accent growing up. In fact, when watching old videos of myself, the first thing that stands out is the heavy Indian accent I had. I never really saw it as a bad thing. One thing you should know about me as a child is that I loved talking. I didn't care who I was talking to or what I was talking about, all I knew was that I...

11-13-2021

 Today, I am unsure on what I should write about. Perhaps I shall write about the weather outside. Right now, at 9:56 AM on this lazy Saturday, clouds roll gently over the sky. The clouds on the right are as white as cotton, while a large gray mass pushes them aside. The day reminds you of an average autumn day: the wind gently swaying branches back and forth, leaves littered on the floor, and cars passing on the road ahead. The day seems calm and carefree now, but I know that the day will soon intensify as time goes on. I have lots of homework that needs to be finished, yet I have such little time.  I cannot spend much of my time to enjoy this pleasant autumn day. It reminds me of the day after Gatsby's heated argument with Tom Buchanan in The Great Gatsby . The day started off with "gray-turning, gold-turning light," with "ghostly birds" singing among the "blue leaves" of the trees. Contrasted with the heat and the constricting feeling of the day bef...

Stronger?

It was club picture day last Tuesday, and here I was, waiting next to the main staircase with the rest of my Science Olympiad team. Right behind us, there was the wall with all the sticky notes written by our students in support of Oxford. With nothing else better to do, my friends and I decided to take a look through each of them. Obviously, most of them were beautifully written. The thought and effort put into these were palpable. There were nice, cute doodles on some of them, words of unison and love on others; some even wrote entire poems! However, there was one sticky note that kind of rubbed me off in the wrong way. There was one sticky note, smack dab in the center, that said, "what doesn't kill you, can only make you stronger." Now as soon as I first saw that, I began to think about how that saying seemed a little tone deaf in this context. Personally, I don't think I would use that phrase to reassure the survivors of one of America's most horrific tragedi...